It's funny you'd mention coincidental cities. I had two separate bookings occur within 2 days of each other. Both bookings were from people allegedly from Bristow, Oklahoma. My listing is in Pennsylvania, so it generally a little odd to see someone renting from OK... but then to have two people book from the EXACT same speck of a midwest town (4,000 residents) was fascinating to say the least and it made me a little suspicious.
There were other coincidences that I won't go into that made me even more curious. I will say that you'd probably need to be a statistician or a actuary to calculate the odds of these individuals renting my house on separate weeks.
One of the guests has come and gone with no problem. Even though he was allegedly from Oklahoma he told me that he was driving from Florida. The other guest will arrive in a few days.
Honestly, I'm not clear what to think. I'm still a little suspicious. Either the tourist bureau of Lancaster PA is doing a bang-up job attracting visitors from Bristow OK; or, the Airbnb system is whacked; or, there's something a bit more nefarious going on that I don't understand.