@Andrew90 Thanks for the suggestions. Yes, instant was turned off during my test searches. I've done a bit of research but will keep digging. My listing is only a week old, so I'm pretty new to this. I've only had to decline one request but it was becuase I had two requests for the sames dates come through at the exact same time. My response rate is 100% and I always reply within 1 hour.
I know if there are a surplus of listings (which there usually are in my neighborhood) it's possible to not show up, but in this case only two or three pages of listings came up for the dates I was testing and I wasn't one of them.
I've noticed that if I test a time period of more than a few days, I show up right away, but if I test search for dates for only two or three nights, I don't show up at all. My minimum stay is set to two nights.
I got over a hundred page views and three bookings the first two days my listing was up and since then only about 10-15 views per day with no bookings.